Governance · Policy comment
Who Is Behind the Challenge?
Verify Smart Corp.'s August 21, 2026 public comment on the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office proposal to identify the real parties in interest behind requests to reexamine a patent.
The company's own case
Verify Smart Corp. v. Askeladden LLC
A policy comment, separate from the status of any patent.
Our patent described a way to check who was making a payment. Then someone challenged our patent, and we had an identity question of our own. Who was asking the government to take a second look?

Designed by Signature |PR
White paper · PDF · 36 pages
Who Is Behind the Challenge?
Anonymous patent reexamination, the honor system, and one company's completed case study.
Read the white paper
Annamarie Seabright · November 12, 2026 · On USPTO Docket No. PTO-P-2025-0545
198
Requests for ex parte reexamination, July–September 2026
35
Of those, filed without naming who was asking
Aug 21, 2026
Verify Smart Corp. comment filed with the Office
In 2017, a company called Askeladden filed the challenge. It listed just one name on the form — its own. We asked the patent board to check. The board said a second name belonged there. It was The Clearing House, the company that owned Askeladden. The board also said the banks that owned The Clearing House could stay off the list. We lost the patent case. But because we asked, a name missing from the record was added.
Why does that matter today? From July through September 2026, the U.S. Patent Office got 198 requests for a different kind of patent review. In 35 of them, the request did not say who was asking. That’s nearly one in five. The law bars some people and companies from bringing the same challenge twice. To enforce that rule, the Patent Office needs to know who brought each challenge.
The Patent Office has proposed a rule that would require names on those requests. We support it. But our case shows why asking for names is only the first step. What happens when a patent owner spots a name that should be on the list? This paper tells the story of how we got one answer changed — and what it would take for the next inventor to be heard.
Sources
- Signed filing, seven pages (PDF) ↗
- Public docket entry PTO-P-2025-0545-0018, Regulations.gov ↗
- “Commenters split on USPTO proposal” — Eileen McDermott, IPWatchdog, August 25, 2026 ↗
- Federal Circuit opinion, Verify Smart Corp. v. Askeladden LLC, August 5, 2020 ↗
This page states the company's position on proposed agency policy. It is not legal advice, not an offer of securities, and does not describe the status of any patent. Company filings on OTC Markets take priority.
In the press · IPWatchdog
August 25, 2026
Commenters Split on USPTO Proposal to Require RPI Disclosure for Reexams
IPWatchdog reviewed the 26 public comments filed on the Office's proposal and found a sharp divide among patent owners, technology companies, industry associations and individuals. Verify Smart Corp. was named among the supporters of a real-party-in-interest requirement, alongside Adeia, Nokia, Dolby Laboratories and the Council for Innovation Promotion.
“Verify Smart pointed to its own lengthy litigation and PTAB history involving Askeladden and The Clearing House Payments Company, LLC, arguing that a disclosure requirement that cannot be challenged and tested risks becoming little more than another honor-system certification. It urged the Office to pair the requirement with stated consequences for material misidentification, a procedure allowing patent owners to contest RPI identifications on an evidentiary record, a continuing duty to correct the disclosure, and — at minimum — access by the patent owner subject to confidentiality safeguards.”

About the author
Eileen McDermott
Editor-in-Chief, IPWatchdog
Eileen McDermott is a veteran intellectual property and legal journalist. She has served as editorial consultant to the International Trademark Association (INTA), overseeing the INTA Bulletin; as Managing Editor and Editor-in-Chief at INTA from 2013 to 2016; as senior consulting editor for the Intellectual Property Owners Association from 2015 to 2017; as a freelance editor for the World Intellectual Property Organization; and as Americas Editor of Managing Intellectual Property magazine from 2007 to 2013.
About IPWatchdog
Founded in 1999 by patent attorney Gene Quinn, IPWatchdog is one of the most widely read independent publications on patents and innovation policy. It is followed closely by patent practitioners, inventors, companies, policymakers and officials at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, and its coverage of agency rulemaking and Federal Circuit decisions is a regular reference point in the intellectual property community.

